Below are recommendations for insurance coverage based on your area’s accident and insurance data. All DecisionData.org recommendations are based on New York data and estimates. The best insurance options for you may vary based on your personal driving record and finances.

Skip to Providers

Accidents per Person

New York

~9 per 1,000 people

USA

~17 per 1,000 people

Should I get cheap car insurance in New York?

Maybe. New York ranks #48 out of 51 for most accidents per person. This estimate suggests that cheap car insurance may be a good idea based on the far below average rate of accidents. We recommend you consider low-deductible plans and providers known for low premiums. See providers below for more help.

Accidents per Mile

New York

~1.4 per million miles

USA

~1.8 per million miles

How much liability coverage should I get?

Probably about the minimum. New Yorkers drive an average of 6,546 per person in the state, which is below the national average of about 9,490. Whether due to long commutes, weather conditions, or bad roads, New Yorkers on average get in less accidents per mile driven. Consider your commute, and think about slightly lower liability coverage.

Uninsured drivers

New York

5.3% uninsured

USA

12.6% uninsured

Should I get comprehensive or liability-only insurance?

Consider liability-only insurance. New York ranks 3rd lowest in the nation for uninsured drivers. Because there are far fewer uninsured drivers in New York, you may want to choose liability-only insurance if your car is paid for and can be replaced without financial strain.

Insurance Cost in New York

Based on the data above, we estimate New York is 2nd out of 51 in affordability. Cheap insurance may be available, even from high-quality providers.

Note on data bars above: The top of each red bar above is the highest value in any state, and the bottom is always 0.

 

Insurance Providers in New York

Provider Benefit summary Customer Rating Purchase link
Geico Low pricing, but sub-par service [star rating=”3″] View plans
Nationwide The best coverage and satisfaction most customers can get; higher premiums [star rating=”4″] View plans
State Farm Good customer service and repair handling; moderate premiums [star rating=”3″] View plans
USAA Superior overall service and pricing – but only available to military members and their families [star rating=”5″] View plans
Progressive High settlement values; low premiums; fair customer service [star rating=”3″] View plans
Allstate Good appraisal process and car rental handling; higher-than-average price [star rating=”3″] View plans
esurance No benefit above average – not recommended [star rating=”2″] View plans
Liberty Mutual Slightly above average in all areas, very high premiums [star rating=”3″] View plans

Sources:

Additional sources